{
  "category": "work",
  "slug": "work-build-board-briefing",
  "title": "Build a Board Briefing from Conflicting Department Updates — Completed Benchmark Result: 8/10",
  "task": "build a board briefing from conflicting department updates",
  "excerpt": "The completed WFT-058 synthetic field test reached 8/10 after one failure-only correction: 4 of five static checks passed for Executive Briefing, while 1 check remained unresolved.",
  "tool": "Codex multi-agent session",
  "model": "Exact underlying model identifier not disclosed by the Codex session",
  "publishedAt": "2026-02-28T11:00:00+08:00",
  "durationMinutes": 0,
  "testMode": "Synthetic benchmark",
  "inputDisclosure": "Synthetic blind-test input pack WFT-058: An executive office will provide finance, sales, operations, and risk updates that disagree on several shared metrics. Source facts: fictional notes WFT-058-N01 through WFT-058-N08 timestamped from 09:05 to 11:40; named roles Lead, Analyst, and Coordinator; a confirmed decision at N03; a tentative suggestion at N05; and conflicting status statements at WFT-058-N06/N07. Governing rule card: the distinction among confirmed decisions, proposals, and unresolved statements. Treat only explicit statements as confirmed; keep proposals tentative; preserve contradictory sources side by side; assign an owner or deadline only when the source supplies one. The pack deliberately contains no answer key, target ranking, expected classification, expected calculation result, or row-level decision. Every person, organization, record, statement, file, and identifier is fictional; no private, production, or live data was supplied.",
  "runDisclosure": "We ran one text-only synthetic benchmark WFT-058 for “build a board briefing from conflicting department updates” in a Codex multi-agent session. We froze the first response, returned only its 2 detected check failures, accepted one corrected response, and scored both against the same five static checks. No external or live action occurred: nothing was sent, published, deployed, uploaded, submitted, purchased, booked, contacted, emailed, called, messaged, executed, or changed outside the fictional text fixtures. No external, live, or production action occurred. Per-case elapsed time was not instrumented during the batch session.",
  "prompt": "Run bounded synthetic field test WFT-058. Task: build a board briefing from conflicting department updates. Context: An executive office will provide finance, sales, operations, and risk updates that disagree on several shared metrics. Fictional source facts: fictional notes WFT-058-N01 through WFT-058-N08 timestamped from 09:05 to 11:40; named roles Lead, Analyst, and Coordinator; a confirmed decision at N03; a tentative suggestion at N05; and conflicting status statements at WFT-058-N06/N07. Governing policy, formula, or rubric: the distinction among confirmed decisions, proposals, and unresolved statements. Treat only explicit statements as confirmed; keep proposals tentative; preserve contradictory sources side by side; assign an owner or deadline only when the source supplies one. Produce a source-linked findings table, concise narrative, and open-question log. Derive every row from the source facts and rule card; show calculations or criterion paths, cite supplied identifiers, state assumptions, surface any violated constraint, ambiguity, missing datum, or source conflict without presuming which row should pass, and abstain where evidence is incomplete. Do not infer an expected answer from the evidence plan and do not claim any live or external action. Planned verification after the frozen response: A claim-to-source ledger will verify every headline number, surface unresolved conflicts, and prevent silent reconciliation.",
  "firstResult": "Frozen first response WFT-058 produced a source-linked findings table, concise narrative, and open-question log for the task “build a board briefing from conflicting department updates.” It treated the supplied pack as fictional and proposed this central handling: record N03 as confirmed, keep N05 explicitly tentative, and expose the WFT-058-N06/N07 conflict instead of choosing a preferred account. Concrete saved artifact row WFT-058-ROW1 reads: “WFT-058-N01 | record N03 as confirmed, keep N05 explicitly tentative, and expose the WFT-058-N06/N07 conflict instead of choosing a preferred account | source: supplied fictional pack | review state: first-draft.” The draft preserved the named records and separated supplied facts from assumptions; its inspectable work product also stated that no message, transaction, system change, or learner outcome had occurred. On the five predeclared static checks, it passed Executive Briefing task fidelity [WFT-058], Executive Briefing rule accuracy [WFT-058], and Executive Briefing handoff usability [WFT-058]. The audit found concrete failures: for Executive Briefing exception handling [WFT-058], the saved draft did not resolve or clearly preserve the tentative N05 statement and the WFT-058-N06/N07 contradiction; for Executive Briefing source traceability [WFT-058], the saved draft gave the central WFT-058-N07 decision no source-to-output locator. Those were evidence defects in the saved response, not inferred real-world failures, and they became the complete boundary of the single correction pass.",
  "correctionPrompt": "Correct only these detected WFT-058 first-draft failures, using no new input or goal: 1) Executive Briefing exception handling [WFT-058] — the draft did not resolve or clearly preserve the tentative N05 statement and the WFT-058-N06/N07 contradiction; 2) Executive Briefing source traceability [WFT-058] — the draft gave the central WFT-058-N07 decision no source-to-output locator.",
  "finalResult": "Corrected response WFT-058 retained the original fictional inputs, task boundary, and central decision: record N03 as confirmed, keep N05 explicitly tentative, and expose the WFT-058-N06/N07 conflict instead of choosing a preferred account. Concrete corrected artifact row WFT-058-ROW1 reads: “WFT-058-N01 | record N03 as confirmed, keep N05 explicitly tentative, and expose the WFT-058-N06/N07 conflict instead of choosing a preferred account | evidence locator: WFT-058-N01 | static status: 8/10 after one correction.” It changed only the detected failure areas, adding inspectable rows for Executive Briefing exception handling [WFT-058]. The frozen final text passed Executive Briefing task fidelity [WFT-058], Executive Briefing rule accuracy [WFT-058], Executive Briefing exception handling [WFT-058], and Executive Briefing handoff usability [WFT-058] and still failed Executive Briefing source traceability [WFT-058]. The final source-linked findings table, concise narrative, and open-question log therefore earned 8/10 from 4 passing checks; no second repair was attempted. This result reports only a bounded transcript-and-fixture evaluation. It does not claim that any workplace process, learner performance, account, device, service, or external system was actually changed, contacted, tested live, or improved.",
  "checks": [
    {
      "name": "Executive Briefing task fidelity [WFT-058]",
      "firstPass": true,
      "finalPass": true,
      "evidence": "WFT-058 static check 1 inspected the saved wording for “Executive Briefing task fidelity [WFT-058].” The first transcript contained enough support; the corrected transcript contained enough support. The comparison used only fictional fixture WFT-058-N07, the declared Executive Briefing rules, and the record’s frozen text; no live outcome or external action counted as evidence."
    },
    {
      "name": "Executive Briefing rule accuracy [WFT-058]",
      "firstPass": true,
      "finalPass": true,
      "evidence": "WFT-058 static check 2 inspected the saved wording for “Executive Briefing rule accuracy [WFT-058].” The first transcript contained enough support; the corrected transcript contained enough support. The comparison used only fictional fixture WFT-058-N07, the declared Executive Briefing rules, and the record’s frozen text; no live outcome or external action counted as evidence."
    },
    {
      "name": "Executive Briefing exception handling [WFT-058]",
      "firstPass": false,
      "finalPass": true,
      "evidence": "WFT-058 static check 3 inspected the saved wording for “Executive Briefing exception handling [WFT-058].” The first transcript did not contain enough support; the corrected transcript contained enough support. The comparison used only fictional fixture WFT-058-N07, the declared Executive Briefing rules, and the record’s frozen text; no live outcome or external action counted as evidence."
    },
    {
      "name": "Executive Briefing source traceability [WFT-058]",
      "firstPass": false,
      "finalPass": false,
      "evidence": "WFT-058 static check 4 inspected the saved wording for “Executive Briefing source traceability [WFT-058].” The first transcript did not contain enough support; the corrected transcript did not contain enough support. The comparison used only fictional fixture WFT-058-N07, the declared Executive Briefing rules, and the record’s frozen text; no live outcome or external action counted as evidence."
    },
    {
      "name": "Executive Briefing handoff usability [WFT-058]",
      "firstPass": true,
      "finalPass": true,
      "evidence": "WFT-058 static check 5 inspected the saved wording for “Executive Briefing handoff usability [WFT-058].” The first transcript contained enough support; the corrected transcript contained enough support. The comparison used only fictional fixture WFT-058-N07, the declared Executive Briefing rules, and the record’s frozen text; no live outcome or external action counted as evidence."
    }
  ],
  "initialScore": 6,
  "score": 8,
  "verdict": "worked",
  "recommended": true,
  "whatWorked": [
    "WFT-058 kept “build a board briefing from conflicting department updates” bounded to disclosed fictional inputs and preserved an auditable first-response snapshot.",
    "WFT-058 made the central handling—record N03 as confirmed, keep N05 explicitly tentative, and expose the WFT-058-N06/N07 conflict instead of choosing a preferred account—inspectable rather than implying unseen work.",
    "WFT-058 earned final passes for Executive Briefing task fidelity [WFT-058] and Executive Briefing rule accuracy [WFT-058] under the same frozen scoring rules."
  ],
  "whatFailed": [
    "WFT-058 still lacked enough saved-text evidence for Executive Briefing source traceability [WFT-058]; the record leaves that final failure visible."
  ],
  "evidencePlan": "A claim-to-source ledger will verify every headline number, surface unresolved conflicts, and prevent silent reconciliation.",
  "evidenceNotes": [
    "WFT-058 preserves the exact synthetic prompt, frozen first-response account, failure-only correction, corrected-response account, and five boolean decisions together.",
    "WFT-058 scores are arithmetic: 3 first-pass checks × 2 = 6/10; 4 final-pass checks × 2 = 8/10.",
    "WFT-058 evaluated only the text/static portion of the declared evidence plan—A claim-to-source ledger will verify every headline number, surface unresolved conflicts, and prevent silent reconciliation.—and did not fabricate a live artifact, external validator, or observed outcome."
  ],
  "limitations": [
    "WFT-058 is a synthetic benchmark, so its worked verdict measures fit to the disclosed fictional Executive Briefing fixtures rather than effectiveness in a real workplace or learning setting.",
    "WFT-058 used one text-only Codex multi-agent session whose underlying model identifier was not disclosed; different prompts, models, fixtures, or human reviewers could produce different results."
  ]
}